The world of mechanical keyboards is a passionate and vibrant community, with enthusiasts constantly debating the merits of different switch types, keyboard layouts, and peripheral features. Among the most hotly contested debates is the question of which Cherry MX switch is superior: Red or Blue? In this article, we’ll delve deep into the world of Cherry MX switches, exploring the history, characteristics, and user experiences of both Red and Blue switches to help you make an informed decision.
What are Cherry MX Switches?
Before we dive into the specifics of Red and Blue switches, it’s essential to understand what makes Cherry MX switches so beloved by keyboard enthusiasts. Cherry Electronics, a German company, has been producing high-quality switches since the 1950s. In the 1980s, they introduced the MX switch line, which quickly became the gold standard for mechanical keyboards.
Cherry MX switches are renowned for their durability, precision, and tactile feedback. They feature a stem-and-housing design, where a spring-loaded stem rises and falls within a plastic housing, registering key presses. This design allows for precise actuation, tactile bump, and audible click, making them a joy to type on.
Cherry MX Red Switches
Cherry MX Red switches are one of the most popular switch types among gamers and typists alike. Introduced in the early 2000s, Red switches were designed to provide a smoother, more linear feel compared to the older Cherry MX Black switches.
Characteristics of Cherry MX Red Switches:
- Actuation force: 45g
- Actuation distance: 2mm
- Total travel distance: 4mm
- Switch type: Linear
- Sound level: Low to moderate
Red switches are known for their:
- Smooth, linear feel
- Low actuation force
- Low noise level
- Fast actuation and reset
Pros of Cherry MX Red Switches
- Suitable for gamers who prefer a light, swift typing experience
- Ideal for those who prefer a quieter typing environment
- Less fatigue-inducing for extended typing sessions
Cons of Cherry MX Red Switches
- May not provide the same level of tactile feedback as other switch types
- Can be prone to accidental key presses due to the low actuation force
Cherry MX Blue Switches
Cherry MX Blue switches, introduced in the late 1990s, were designed to provide a more pronounced tactile bump and audible click compared to earlier switch designs.
Characteristics of Cherry MX Blue Switches:
- Actuation force: 50g
- Actuation distance: 2.2mm
- Total travel distance: 4mm
- Switch type: Tactile and Clicky
- Sound level: Loud
Blue switches are known for their:
- Distinct, tactile bump
- Loud, audible click
- Higher actuation force
- Slightly slower actuation and reset
Pros of Cherry MX Blue Switches
- Provides a clear, tactile indicator of key registration
- Suitable for typists who prefer a more deliberate, forceful typing experience
- Can help reduce typos due to the distinct bump and click
Cons of Cherry MX Blue Switches
- May be too loud for shared workspaces or quiet environments
- Can be fatiguing for extended typing sessions due to the higher actuation force
Comparison of Cherry MX Red and Blue Switches
Now that we’ve explored the characteristics and pros and cons of each switch type, let’s directly compare Cherry MX Red and Blue switches.
Type
| Switch Type | Actuation Force | Actuation Distance | Total Travel Distance | Sound Level |
| — | — | — | — | — |
| Cherry MX Red | 45g | 2mm | 4mm | Low to Moderate |
| Cherry MX Blue | 50g | 2.2mm | 4mm | Loud |
Typing Experience
Cherry MX Red switches provide a smooth, linear feel, making them suitable for gamers and typists who prefer a light, swift typing experience. Cherry MX Blue switches, on the other hand, offer a more pronounced tactile bump and audible click, making them ideal for typists who prefer a more deliberate, forceful typing experience.
Gaming Performance
Both Red and Blue switches are suitable for gaming, but Red switches are often preferred by gamers due to their faster actuation and reset times. However, Blue switches can provide a more tactile and audible feedback, which can be beneficial for games that require precision and timing.
User Experience and Preferences
Ultimately, the choice between Cherry MX Red and Blue switches comes down to personal preference. We spoke with several keyboard enthusiasts and gamers to gather their thoughts on the two switch types.
“I prefer Red switches for gaming because they allow me to move quickly and accurately across the keyboard. The low actuation force also reduces fatigue during long gaming sessions.” – John, Gamer
“I’m a fan of Blue switches for typing because I like the tactile feedback and audible click. It helps me stay focused and avoid typos.” – Sarah, Typist
Conclusion
Is Cherry MX Red better than Blue? The answer is subjective and depends on your personal preferences, typing style, and needs. If you’re a gamer or typist who prefers a smooth, linear feel and a quieter typing experience, Cherry MX Red switches may be the better choice. If you’re a typist who prefers a more deliberate, forceful typing experience with distinct tactile feedback and an audible click, Cherry MX Blue switches are the way to go.
Ultimately, the debate between Cherry MX Red and Blue switches is a testament to the diversity of preferences within the keyboard community. Whether you’re a gamer, typist, or simply a keyboard enthusiast, there’s a Cherry MX switch type that’s perfect for you.
What are Cherry MX switches and why do they matter?
Cherry MX switches are a type of mechanical switch used in computer keyboards. They are considered to be one of the highest-quality and most popular switch types among keyboard enthusiasts. Cherry MX switches are known for their durability, tactile feedback, and precision, making them a crucial component of a keyboard’s overall performance. Whether you’re a professional typist, gamer, or just an everyday user, the type of switch used in your keyboard can greatly impact your typing experience.
The reason Cherry MX switches matter is that they can affect the overall feel and sound of a keyboard. Different switch types offer distinct characteristics, such as actuation force, travel distance, and sound level, which can cater to individual preferences. For instance, some users prefer a more tactile and clicky feedback, while others prefer a smoother and quieter experience. By choosing the right Cherry MX switch type, users can optimize their keyboard to fit their specific needs and typing style.
What is the main difference between Cherry MX Red and Blue switches?
The main difference between Cherry MX Red and Blue switches lies in their tactile feedback, actuation force, and sound level. Cherry MX Red switches are known for their linear, smooth, and quiet operation, with an actuation force of 45g and a total travel distance of 4mm. On the other hand, Cherry MX Blue switches are tactile and clicky, with an actuation force of 50g and a total travel distance of 4mm. The Blue switches have a more pronounced bump and audible click when pressed, which can be beneficial for typists who require tactile feedback.
The choice between Red and Blue switches ultimately comes down to personal preference. If you prefer a more subtle and quiet typing experience, the Red switches might be the better option. However, if you require a more tactile and audible feedback to type accurately, the Blue switches could be the way to go. It’s worth noting that the Blue switches can be louder and may not be suitable for shared workspaces or quiet environments.
Are Cherry MX Red switches better for gaming?
Cherry MX Red switches are often considered a popular choice among gamers due to their fast and quiet operation. The linear, non-tactile design allows for rapid key presses and releases, making them well-suited for fast-paced games that require quick reflexes. Additionally, the Red switches have a slightly shorter actuation distance than the Blue switches, which can give gamers a slight edge in terms of response time.
However, it’s essential to note that the choice of switch type ultimately depends on the individual gamer’s preferences and playing style. Some gamers might prefer the tactile feedback of the Blue switches to ensure they’ve registered a key press accurately. Others might prefer the Red switches for their speed and quietness. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference and experimentation with different switch types.
Are Cherry MX Blue switches better for typing?
Cherry MX Blue switches are often preferred by typists who require tactile feedback to type accurately. The audible click and tactile bump provided by the Blue switches can help typists maintain a consistent typing rhythm and reduce errors. The slightly heavier actuation force of the Blue switches can also help typists develop finger strength and typing muscle memory.
However, it’s worth noting that the Blue switches can be fatiguing to type on for extended periods due to their heavier actuation force. Additionally, the audible click can be distracting in shared workspaces or quiet environments. Some typists might prefer the quieter and smoother operation of the Red switches, which can provide a more comfortable typing experience.
Can I replace my existing keyboard switches with Cherry MX Red or Blue?
Yes, it is possible to replace your existing keyboard switches with Cherry MX Red or Blue switches. However, this process often requires technical expertise and can be time-consuming. Keyboard switches are typically mounted on a PCB (printed circuit board) and require desoldering and resoldering to replace.
It’s essential to ensure that the new switches are compatible with your keyboard’s PCB and design. Additionally, switching to a different switch type can affect the overall feel and sound of your keyboard. If you’re not comfortable with DIY projects, it might be better to purchase a new keyboard with the desired switch type.
What are some alternatives to Cherry MX Red and Blue switches?
There are several alternatives to Cherry MX Red and Blue switches, including other Cherry MX switch types, such as Brown, Black, and Clear. Other manufacturers, such as Kailh, Outemu, and Razer, also offer their own versions of mechanical switches. These alternatives can offer distinct characteristics, such as different actuation forces, travel distances, and sound levels.
Some users might prefer these alternatives due to their unique features or cost-effectiveness. For instance, Kailh switches are known for their similar quality to Cherry MX switches but at a lower price point. However, it’s essential to research and compare the features and performance of these alternatives to determine which one best suits your needs.
Is it worth trying out different Cherry MX switch types?
Yes, it’s definitely worth trying out different Cherry MX switch types to determine which one suits your needs best. Many keyboard enthusiasts swear by trying out different switch types before committing to a particular one. This can help you develop a personal preference and optimize your typing or gaming experience.
You can try out different switch types by purchasing switch testers, which are small devices that feature multiple switch types on a single board. This allows you to experience the feel and sound of different switches without committing to a full keyboard purchase. Additionally, many keyboard manufacturers offer switch swapping services or trial programs, allowing you to try out different switch types before making a purchase.